Yes, for most homes a stainless steel litter box is better than plastic. Not because it's shiny, and not because a company with a nice Instagram told you so. It's better because it doesn't scratch, and scratches are where the smell lives.

If you've ever scrubbed a plastic box until your arms hurt, refilled it with fresh litter, and still walked past it an hour later thinking "why does it smell like that," this post is for you. Plastic still has a few things going for it, though, so here's the honest version, with what veterinarians actually say.

Why your plastic litter box smells even after you clean it

Your cat is not a gentle digger. Every visit to the box is a small excavation project, and every one of those claw strokes leaves a scratch in the plastic. One scratch is nothing. A few hundred visits later, the bottom of the box looks like an ice rink after a hockey game.

Those grooves are the problem. Autumn Vetter, a veterinarian and clinical professor at the University of Georgia College of Veterinary Medicine, told Inverse that deep scratches in plastic create more spots for bacteria to hide, and that plastic is more porous than steel to begin with. Your sponge glides right over them. The bacteria stay home.

So when the box smells no matter what you do, it isn't you. The box has quietly become part of the problem. Cat behavior consultant Mikel Delgado says a plastic box should be replaced every one to two years, depending on how chewed up it gets. Most people keep theirs a lot longer than that. (No judgment. Nobody puts "buy new litter box" on the calendar.)

Smell can also be an airflow issue, especially if the box lives in a cabinet. We dig into that in will a litter box cabinet make the smell worse?

What stainless steel does better

There's a reason vet hospitals and animal shelters use stainless steel. Those places deal with more cats, more germs and more cleaning than any home ever will. Vetter told UGA Today that stainless steel litter boxes are "largely impervious to scratches." Her hospital runs its boxes through an industrial cage wash between patients. Your cat, however determined, is not going to out-dig a cage wash.

  • It stays smooth. No scratches means nowhere for bacteria and odor to set up camp.
  • Clumps don't cling. Waste slides off steel instead of welding itself to the walls like it does on worn plastic.
  • You buy it once. A steel box doesn't wear out on a one-to-two-year schedule. It's closer to buying a good pan than a paper plate.

Where plastic still wins

Steel isn't perfect, and both experts were clear that it isn't automatically the right box for every home. Plastic has a real case:

  • It's cheap. Cuteness found basic plastic boxes for as little as $5. Stainless steel runs about $20 to $50 or more.
  • It's light. Carrying a full steel box to the bathtub to wash it is a workout you didn't sign up for.
  • It comes in every shape imaginable. Covered, top entry, corner, tiny, enormous. Steel has fewer options.
  • Your cat gets a vote. Delgado notes some cats just don't like how steel feels under their paws. Cats are famous for having opinions about things you'd never think to have an opinion about. This is one of them.

Stainless steel vs plastic litter box

Stainless steel Plastic
Scratches Largely scratch-proof Scratches with every dig
Smell over time Doesn't hold on to it Gets worse as it wears
How long it lasts No replacement schedule Replace every 1 to 2 years
Price About $20 to $50+ From about $5
Weight Heavier Lighter
Styles Open high-sided and top entry Nearly every style there is

So should you switch?

One healthy cat: you'd be fine either way, but steel is the better buy if you're keeping it more than a couple of years. You stop buying replacement boxes, and you stop fighting a box that smells no matter what.

Two or more cats: switch. Vetter says that with one cat, passing germs between cats isn't a concern. With several, bacteria hanging around a scratched-up box can still cause trouble for a cat with a weaker immune system. If cat number two is on the way, read how to introduce two cats first. The litter box is only one of the things they'll fight over.

A cat with strong opinions: try steel, but leave the old box out for a week. If your cat starts going right next to the new box with full eye contact, you have your answer.

How big should the box be?

Bigger than you think. Most boxes on store shelves are too small, steel or plastic. The University of Illinois Veterinary Teaching Hospital recommends a box about 1.5 times your cat's length, measured from the nose to the base of the tail. Not counting the tail, which is a relief, because measuring a cat's tail is a two-person job.

The same handout recommends one box per cat, plus one extra. Two cats, three boxes. Yes, really.

How to keep any litter box clean

Steel makes cleaning easier. It does not make cleaning optional. The University of Illinois handout recommends:

  • Scooping at least once a day.
  • Dumping and washing the whole box every 1 to 4 weeks with hot water and soap.
  • Skipping harsh chemicals and anything with ammonia. To a cat, ammonia smells like another cat already used the bathroom, and they'll go elsewhere.
  • Drying it all the way before you add fresh litter.

The handout also says most cats prefer soft, unscented clumping litter. The lavender-scented stuff is for you, not them. If you're curious what you're actually pouring in there, here's what cat litter is made of.

How to hide a stainless steel litter box

Here's the downside nobody puts in the product photos: a stainless steel litter box looks like something borrowed from a restaurant kitchen. It's clean, it's practical, and it's not going to win any design awards in your living room.

A litter box enclosure solves that. It turns the box into a cabinet or side table, hides it from guests, and gives flying litter a wall to hit instead of your floor. Browse our litter box furniture, or start with one of these:

Measure before you buy. Steel boxes usually have tall sides, so check the enclosure's inside height as well as width. And keep the opening wide. The Illinois handout warns that tight, closed-in spaces make some cats anxious about using the box, and an anxious cat finds creative alternatives.

Hate scooping more than smell?

Then the material isn't really your problem. A self-cleaning box is. We carry an open-top self-cleaning litter box and a larger self-cleaning litter box for multiple cats. Steel fixes a box that won't stay clean. A self-cleaning box fixes a human who doesn't want to scoop. Know which one you are.

Stainless steel litter box FAQ

Do stainless steel litter boxes smell less?

Over time, yes. Steel doesn't scratch or absorb odor the way plastic does, so it doesn't build up that permanent litter box smell. You still have to scoop.

Do cats like stainless steel litter boxes?

Most cats use them with no problem. Some don't like the feel under their paws. Keep the old box around for the first week so your cat can weigh in.

How often should you replace a plastic litter box?

Every one to two years, depending on how scratched it is, according to cat behavior consultant Mikel Delgado.

How many litter boxes do I need?

One per cat, plus one extra, according to the University of Illinois Veterinary Teaching Hospital.